Do You Ignore the Advice that you Pay to Receive?
ADVICE. How do you feel about that word? A friend once told me about a late-night car ride where the driver got lost and asked passengers for directions — twice. Both times, the suggestions were ignored. The third request was met with silence.
It’s one thing to ignore free advice. It’s another to ignore advice you’ve paid hundreds of dollars an hour for. Ask any financial planner, physician, or consultant: people often don’t take the advice they’re given, usually to their own detriment — and in business, ignoring good advice can waste time, effort, and human resources worth millions of dollars.
One type of advice businesses sometimes ignore: their own employee survey results. Robert S. Kaplan and David P. Norton, authors of The Strategy-Focused Organization, report that hundreds of portfolio managers rank the ability to execute a strategy above the quality of the strategy itself — yet research indicates fewer than 10 percent of strategies are ever successfully implemented. A vision is worthless if it’s never put into practice.
The difference between advice acted on and advice ignored shows up clearly in an NBRI case study. A large IT solutions company’s first employee survey identified two root causes — via Root Cause Analysis (RCA) — driving 44% of all survey items: “My manager motivates me” and “The company values its individual teammates.” Both scored in the “opportunities” range, meaning plenty of room for improvement.
A year later, the follow-up survey told a mixed story. The company had acted only on the primary root cause — and saw a significant positive shift in “My manager motivates me,” which in turn drove a positive change in 79% of the items it influenced. But the secondary root cause, left unaddressed, moved in the wrong direction: 57% of the items it drove got worse. The lesson: acting on part of the advice isn’t the same as acting on all of it.
Kaplan and Norton point to two reasons organizations struggle to execute even well-formulated strategy: their measurement tools haven’t kept pace with how fast strategy needs to change, and outdated, incremental rollout approaches can’t keep up with a fast-moving environment. Scientifically sound research — paired with a technique like Root Cause Analysis — addresses both: it measures whether a strategy is working and tells you exactly where to focus next, taking the guesswork out of the intervention process.
One caution: be wary of any firm that offers to both diagnose your problems and sell you the solution — that’s a conflict of interest. A reputable research firm advises on the improvement process; it doesn’t try to sell you the fix.
If you’d rather learn the easy way, contact NBRI at 800-756-6168 to learn how scientific research and Root Cause Analysis can support your continuous improvement process.
NBRI Research Team
National Business Research Institute
























By submitting this form you agree to our