Employer of Choice: Managing Coworker Relationships
Organizations — for-profit or non-profit — accomplish more through people working together than through any single individual. The quality of coworker relationships explains why some small teams are remarkably productive while other, better-resourced teams remain lethargic.
Strong coworker relationships help teams resolve problems early, before disagreements become disruptive and disproportionately damaging. Managing the following five factors can help immunize your organization against recurring, disabling people-problems at work.
Limited Resources
Conflict often correlates with competition for scarce resources — too few printers, too little parking, too tight a budget. Forcing people to compete for resources tends to increase conflict.
Hint: look for bottlenecks and sources of friction and fix them. Often the issue isn’t a lack of resources but inefficient use of what you already have.
Zero-Sum Games
A zero-sum game occurs when one person’s win requires another’s loss — competing for a single open position, for example. These situations reduce communication, cooperation, and teamwork, and the disruption can scale from individuals up to entire departments or divisions.
Reality: many zero-sum games are unavoidable. Alternative: use an employee survey or other fact-finding tool to identify and redefine the unnecessary ones — is rewarding only the single top performer better than rewarding everyone who exceeds a shared goal? Tip: rewarding individual achievement over team achievement is itself a way of creating a zero-sum game, so examine your recognition structure if a team has a history of low teamwork.
Fear
Fear destroys relationships, commitment, and innovation, and is frequently the byproduct of blame or excessive criticism. Organizations that focus on “who did it” create a culture of blame; organizations that focus on what about their process allowed a mistake to happen create a culture of improvement. Employee surveys can surface exactly which process gaps need attention. Underlying causes worth examining: do people have enough authority to solve problems when they occur? Is there a hostile environment for new ideas — one where an imperfect first draft of an idea permanently brands its author as incompetent?
Fairness
Every management decision is reviewed for fairness by employees, with the highest scrutiny reserved for pay, opportunities, and recognition. Disagreements about fairness often trace back to two competing views — equal treatment for everyone versus rewards proportional to contribution. The criteria for raises, promotions, and recognition should be explicit and clear, with more rigid guidelines for larger rewards and more latitude for smaller ones. Comparing actual pay against the perception of fair pay, our research consistently finds that perceived fairness is more powerful than net pay itself.
Communication
Organizations don’t exist without communication — establishing roles, values, goals, and reward structures all depend on it. In white-collar organizations especially, teamwork is largely the act of communicating with coworkers to get things done. Teamwork within a workgroup is easier to manage than teamwork across workgroups, which typically requires managers to actively define expectations between departments; employee survey data consistently confirms this.
We’re also more likely to trust and include people we perceive as similar to ourselves — an instinct that isn’t limited to race or gender, and can isolate people based on almost any arbitrary, hard-to-change trait. Managers who actively work against that exclusion make a measurable difference in how long employees stay and how much they’re able to contribute.
Managing coworker relationships is challenging — people don’t come with instruction manuals. But a workplace with adequate resources, minimal unnecessary zero-sum games, low fear, fairness, and good communication will see the payoff in greater engagement, satisfaction, tenure, and productivity. A quantitative diagnosis — an employee survey — helps identify exactly which issues are a problem, where, and to what extent.
If you would like to learn more, please contact NBRI at 800-756-6168.
NBRI Research Team
National Business Research Institute
























By submitting this form you agree to our